BREAKING

Criptomonedas Legal

My Crypto Lawyer Sec Speeches Cryptocurrency Considering the Materiality of Financial Information in Municipal Disclosure


Hello, everyone.

As is customary, the views I express today are provided in my official capacity as the Commission’s Director of the Office of Municipal Securities (“OMS”), but do not necessarily reflect the views of the Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”), the Commissioners, or other members of the staff.  Additionally, we very much welcome and encourage feedback from market participants on both the views shared today as well as with respect to long-standing rules and guidance related to the topics covered today. 

Thank you to NABL for the invitation to be here.  I want to use my time today to discuss a topic that is fundamental to municipal disclosure: evaluating what financial information, especially financial statements, is material to investors and what information, while accurate, has the potential to be misleading. I also want to spend a few moments discussing the involvement of bond counsel in developing and disclosing issuer project selection criteria for conduit issuances.

Materiality in Financial Disclosure

Materiality is the key to the disclosure regime for securities generally, including municipal securities.  As you are well aware from the opinions you issue, the federal securities laws make it unlawful, in connection with the purchase or sale of any security, to make any untrue statement of a material fact or to omit to state a material fact necessary in order to make the statements made, in the light of the circumstances under which they were made, not misleading. In the municipal, this is the bedrock principle that guides the decision-making of professionals like disclosure counsel, bond counsel, and underwriter’s counsel.

The Supreme Court has defined a material fact as one for which there is a substantial likelihood that its disclosure would be viewed by the reasonable investor as significantly altering the total mix of information made available. Our Chairman, Paul Atkins, has emphasized the importance of materiality in numerous statements he has made since becoming Chairman. In remarks earlier this summer, Chairman Atkins stated that one of his top priorities is to restore the public company disclosure regime to one rooted in materiality, noting that this term has recently been hijacked or substituted with phrases such as “double materiality” or “decision useful,” which have no standing in the relevant jurisprudence. Another of our Commissioners, Hester Peirce, remarked earlier this year that while it is not unreasonable to consider non-economic factors when investing, fulfilling the SEC’s  foremost policy objective, protecting investors, requires us to ensure that investors have access to material financial information. So with those principles in mind, I’d like to discuss my views on what financial information may or may not be material to a reasonable investor under certain circumstances, particularly in municipal structures where the general credit of the issuer or obligated person is not pledged to the repayment of the bonds.

Financial statements are often the most critical disclosure for investors. Rule 15c2-12 provides that a Participating Underwriter may not purchase or sell municipal securities in connection with an offering unless it has reasonably determined that an issuer or obligated person (or persons) whose financial or operating data is presented in the final official statement has undertaken to provide, among other things, annual financial information, specifically including audited financial statements.  Rule 15c2-12 further notes, in its definition of “final official statement,” that the official statement should include financial information concerning issuers and other persons material to an evaluation of the offering. 

After the Commission adopted the 1994 amendments to Rule 15c2-12, NABL asked the Commission staff a number of clarifying questions, which resulted in two letters from the staff to NABL that we affectionately refer to as “NABL 1” and “NABL 2.”  In NABL 2, NABL asked the staff about the requirement in Rule 15c2-12 to deliver audited financial statements as part of its annual financial information in the case of certain limited obligation bonds, where the issuer may choose not to include its audited financial statements in the official statement because the bonds are not payable from the issuer’s general assets or because the source of payment for the bonds did not exist at the time.  This question gets to the heart of the materiality debate – what information should a reasonable investor have access to in order to make an investment decision?

At the time, the staff responded by stating that if audited financial statements are not prepared with respect to the specific funds and accounts pledged to repayment of the bonds, the issuer, if an obligated person, is required to submit its financial statements, regardless of whether separate information regarding such funds or accounts, or related underlying assets, is separately presented. In light of our Commissioners’ recent focus on financial materiality, I think it is time to reevaluate that staff statement.

The inclusion of financial statements in an official statement or continuing disclosure submission is designed to give investors the financial information they need to make an investment decision.  They provide the quantitative foundation for assessing credit risk, fiscal health, and the issuer’s capacity to meet its obligations to repay the bonds. However, in my view, if an issuer’s financial statements do not contain that information with respect to the particular bonds being offered, they may not be material to the decision made by a reasonable investor. Furthermore, if the bonds are not payable from accounts presented in the financial statements, the inclusion of such statements may even misleading.  

To expand on the example from NABL 2, let’s say a bond issue is payable only from a specific percentage of a specific local tax, and that the applicable percentage is deposited into a dedicated fund before it reaches the issuer’s general fund.  Will the financial statements of that issuer provide any information that is useful to a reasonable investor in determining the likelihood of payment default?  The answer may be yes or no, but like so many things in securities law, it depends on the facts and circumstances, including of that particular financing structure and how that fund is presented in the financial statements. 

Another example not covered in NABL 1 or NABL 2 is where the bonds are secured by a direct pay letter of credit.  In that structure, generally the principal and interest on the bonds is paid directly by the credit provider to the bondholders, and the obligation of the issuer or obligated person runs only to the provider.  In such a structure, is information about the financial condition of the issuer or obligated person material to a reasonable investor?  Again, it may or may not be, depending on the facts and circumstances, which could include a number of things, such as acceleration provisions based on the issuer’s ability to pay the provider or comply with certain financial covenants. 

In both of these examples, again depending on the facts and circumstances, it may even be the case that the inclusion of the issuer’s financial statements could mislead reasonable investors by directing them to information that does not impact the particular bonds.

As bond lawyers, you are frequently advising your clients as to what information should or should not be included in their primary and secondary market disclosure documents.  That means you are helping your clients make judgments regarding materiality.  You also are well positioned to understand the often complex structures in our market and to evaluate the particular facts and circumstances of each offering in order to determine what financial information is material to a reasonable investor.. 

I would like to add here that your evaluation should be independent, and not conditioned on what information third-party entities, such as rating agencies, require.  We have seen several instances over the years where one or more rating agencies have conflated an event that relates to one issue of outstanding bonds with other, differently secured bonds of the same issuer, even though one may not be material to the other.  In fact, the published methodologies of some rating agencies explicitly state that they will consider financial information of a municipal issuer beyond the credit of the specific bonds being rated.  One example you may be familiar with occurred in 2018, when Platte County, Missouri chose not to appropriate funds to pay an issue of subject-to-appropriation bonds. Moody’s and S&P both downgraded the county itself, which included its other outstanding bonds that were general obligations not subject to appropriation. In that instance, Moody’s explicitly stated that there had been no change in the underlying credit characteristics which, absent the county’s current position regarding the appropriation bonds, would correspond to a much higher rating.  County attorneys countered that whether or not the county made a voluntary payment on the appropriation bonds had no bearing on its ability and willingness to pay its legal obligations. In this instance, the county and the rating agencies essentially disagreed on what was material to holders of the county’s securities.  As bond or disclosure counsel, you are making similar evaluations on a daily basis, and I urge you to consider the principles of materiality as expressed by courts and most recently by our esteemed SEC Commissioners.

Project Selection in Conduit Financings

Earlier this year, I spoke to a conference of conduit municipal issuers about the importance of disclosure of their project selection process.  Those comments also are relevant to you as counsel to those issuers. Conduit issuers serve as gatekeepers because they select which borrowers can access the municipal securities market. However, many times, the process used by those issuers to select the projects they will be financing on behalf of conduit borrowers is not disclosed. Depending upon the facts and circumstances, that may be a disclosure issue because investors may not be able to properly evaluate the level of risk they are taking on – in essence making a blind investment – when they do not have material information about the project selection and evaluation process.

As I see it, a lack of transparency in the project selection and evaluation process could make it unclear to an investor what type of vetting, if any, a conduit issuer has performed for the projects they finance. Investors may mistakenly assume that what appears to be a governmental issuer’s involvement in the conduit financing implies a rigorous or statutorily determined vetting process; or an investor may mistakenly assume that all conduit issuers have similar vetting processes for the projects they approve, even though, from what I have observed, these processes do vary widely across conduit issuers.

I am encouraged when I see conduit issuers who have clearly stated policies or guidelines establishing the creditworthiness standards and eligibility requirements for the projects they will finance, such as: requiring a minimum investment-grade rating, and if unrated, requiring forms of credit enhancements; demonstration of revenue generation or repayment ability of the conduit borrower through feasibility studies conducted by the borrower’s consultants; and alignment with a public benefit, particularly for 501(c)(3) borrowers.

To be clear, I am not suggesting specific standards and/or eligibility requirements for your project selection or evaluation process. However, I believe that conduit issuers that utilize rating reports and feasibility studies, especially for specialized projects, and conduct an independent analysis of these reports and studies to ensure compliance with statutory and financing eligibility requirements and then share this information publicly, may leave investors in a better position to evaluate the risks of a conduit financed project. I ask that, when serving as bond or disclosure counsel to a conduit issuer, you evaluate your client’s project selection and evaluation criteria and encourage the issuer to disclose them.

The diligence, judgment, and commitment to best practices of the NABL community help to ensure that investors have access to the information they need to make informed decisions. Let us continue to build a market defined by clarity, trust, and accountability.

Thank you again to NABL for the opportunity to discuss these issues with you today.



Enlace de My Crypto Lawyer